Westeros.org on Game of Thrones: Episode 6, "The Iron Throne"

Share
HTML-code
  • Published: 20 May 2019
  • Linda Antonsson of Westeros.org returns to discuss the 6th and final episode of Season 8. For more, see the episode guide at westeros.org/GoT/Episodes/Entry/The_Iron_Throne
    #Gameofthrones #Westeros #Review
  • Entertainment Entertainment

Comments • 164

  • Anai Bendai
    Anai Bendai  5 months back

    They ruined GAME OF THRONES. "oh the humanity... ". I was so embarrassed watching the finale because I was in a room full of people I'd converted to GoT and I felt SO bad that I got them into this cringey, awful, just awfully conceived and written ending... what started so promising and so awesome in seasons 1-5 just crumbled into a horrific mess of amateurish plotting and dialogue in the end. I thought about slinking out of the room as everyone sat there angrily with confused, irritated and annoyed looks on their faces but I stuck it out and when it was done - we all had that wounded "what the fuck happened?" conversation - kind of like the one we had after THE PHANTOM MENACE back in 99 and wondered how something so good could go so terribly wrong.

    • Colin Evans
      Colin Evans  5 months back

      You're awesome Linda, your sass perfectly sums up my feelings towards this garbage fire of a show

      • Joseph Ballin
        Joseph Ballin  6 months back

        Pretty much the worst season in existence.

        • Jason Spears
          Jason Spears  6 months back

          This reviewer is way too cool for her own good.

          • DasEichenlaub
            DasEichenlaub  6 months back

            Yup. Id say the show definitely started to fall apart during season 2. They never handled dany right. They never understood dany. Because they never understood the books. They never even understood their own show. They have always been hack frauds

            • Filipa Antonia Barata de Araujo

              Though I quite liked the ending, I understand what you're saying. It really felt a bit empty. We should have at least seen a bit more of the world. And the fact Jon was a Targaryen should have been given more weight, the fact that Aegon Targaryen finished what the first Aegon Targaryen started. I don't think Bran manipulated the events, but he realized, when Jon decided to tell Sansa and Arya he was Aegon, that things could only one in one way. Or maybe he realized he was the best king Westeros could have. It's ambivalent and should have been more explored.

              • Chris B
                Chris B  6 months back

                I absolutely loved season one and two but there was nothing about season 8 that I liked and felt completely let down by the final episode

                • Sophia Wilson
                  Sophia Wilson  6 months back

                  They skip many plots of the books they didn't past it.

                  • Brandon Guimond
                    Brandon Guimond  6 months back

                    That may be the best analogy I've heard...."GOT was kind of like the Hindenburgh...it just sort of blew up in mid air".

                    • Orgasmatron76
                      Orgasmatron76  6 months back

                      The show ended terribly - there’s no hiding how terrible D&D are as writers - producers. I feel like they intentionally destroyed or tried to diminish the brand GRRM created. Your knowledge & attention to detail is always appreciated, I’m so glad that you guys both Elio & Linda are eternally connected to George & his masterpieces - I pray we will all get to know his complete story sticking it up the “Ass” of all that went wrong with the TV Show. I hope to hear more from you on many other projects over time

                      • Bob Belcher
                        Bob Belcher  6 months back

                        to sit around there and count the snowflakes falling or something lol

                        • kmsharley75
                          kmsharley75  6 months back

                          Hindenburg analogy is spot on. This show blew up in the sky.

                          • Matthew Chung
                            Matthew Chung  6 months back

                            yeah the landing did not stick at all but the ending montage was a visual/aural treat. I really liked the montage of seeing each character's silhouette and their weapons/accessories/outfits.

                            • EATHER2468
                              EATHER2468  6 months back

                              Maybe Arya ends up destroying kingslanding by her pursuit of killing cersi which triggers the wildfire in Kings landing.

                              • merkavah4
                                merkavah4  6 months back

                                You don't remember all those episodes where Arya expressed her desire to become a master cartographer?

                                • Grallon Sphere
                                  Grallon Sphere  6 months back

                                  You and your husband *need* to help GRRM finish those books now. I think you're both the only ones who could, and whom he would trust, to do so.

                                  • Craig Leska
                                    Craig Leska  6 months back

                                    Thanks for doing this Linda. It was nice to have a solid book-based perspective to turn to during the last few seasons.

                                    • Baptiste J.
                                      Baptiste J.  6 months back

                                      The death scene of Dany, with Drogon trying to nudge her, and then taking her away, was probably the scene that I loved the most in the entire season.
                                      But then again, I love every scene that shows that dragons are much more than nuclear weapons, so...

                                      • S R
                                        S R  6 months back

                                        "Sansa looks ominous"? It's sad that even now after the endgame there are anti comments directed at her. She inspired Jon to take back their home, she's been a great Lady of Winterfell according to her people, she supported Bran and Jon multiple times as rulers of Winterfell without trying to take that throne even though the lords themselves offered it to her. She tried to protect her pack the whole way through. She supports her family and people. Why is she dark and ominous?

                                        • Julia Da
                                          Julia Da  6 months back

                                          want to break the wheel of great Lords fighting for power
                                          -->install system where great lords have to squabble over who will rule next every few years

                                          • Jordy R
                                            Jordy R  6 months back

                                            Your ending on this video was better than the ending of the show ha

                                            • Murdo2112
                                              Murdo2112  6 months back

                                              What should have been the final scene:

                                              As Jon Snow trots along with the beginnings of his stupid, smug smirk, the camera pulls out and up and flies over the Haunted Forest , away over the Frostfangs, to the Lands of Always Winter and the citadel we glimpsed in season 4.
                                              There sits a truly awesome looking Other, on a frozen throne, who speaks in a voice like shattering ice.
                                              The subtitles read "So, my lieutenant has failed... I suppose I must do this myself".
                                              The camera pulls back to show thousands of Others silently mounting their giant ice spiders ....
                                              Roll credits.

                                              • Mon Sneaks
                                                Mon Sneaks  6 months back

                                                Oh I like the idea of Arya seeing Cat. Wonderful

                                                • manudosde
                                                  manudosde  6 months back

                                                  I've enjoyed all your content through the years, so I hope the videos keep coming. Thanks for your good work, Elio and Linda.

                                                  • Sandrine Pantel
                                                    Sandrine Pantel  6 months back

                                                    Bran going back North with Jon would have been sooo much better!

                                                    • rgoodwyn
                                                      rgoodwyn  6 months back

                                                      Yes! Sansa could have been Queen to keep the north in the fold and Bran could have returned to where he belonged as the Three Eyed Raven.

                                                  • Erikkolai
                                                    Erikkolai  6 months back

                                                    I've always watched but never commented. Wanted to thank you for these videos, it's been a great way to decompress after begrudgingly watching the show.

                                                    • Natalie Daniels
                                                      Natalie Daniels  6 months back

                                                      Linda thank you so much for your insightful reviews! I've enjoyed them immensely. Hopefully you and Elio will be doing videos about TWOW soon.

                                                      Dany's liberation line made her sound like a neocon politician. So anachronistic and out of place.

                                                      Thanks for your eye rolls and hot takes.

                                                      • TheThermidorian
                                                        TheThermidorian  6 months back

                                                        Didn’t they change it so that the three-eyed raven lives for thousands of years, or something? So is Bran going to be King for a thousand years?

                                                        • morton somerville
                                                          morton somerville  6 months back

                                                          Jon snow was banished, not Aegon Targaryen

                                                          • MotherofDragon
                                                            MotherofDragon  6 months back

                                                            Ironic that D&D would chose "stories" as the thing that binds us together. If they were better at writing stories, we would not have lost the internal consistency that made GOT the incredible phenomenon that it was. I felt such an incredible sense of loss watching the characters literally burn at the hands of these two. The actors, music, cinematography, effects and costumes were however...absolutely stunning! heartbreaking. Yes..Yes.. Linda, you hit the nail on the head! As it neared the end... it got small.

                                                            • David Robinson
                                                              David Robinson  6 months back

                                                              Thanks for all the time you and Elio put into reviewing the TV show. I'm sure we all hope for many more insights into the wonderful world of ice and fire in the future.

                                                              • Emm
                                                                Emm  6 months back

                                                                I’m very excited the show is over so all my favourite Game of Thrones youtube channels can make videos only about the books again! 😊👏

                                                                • Edwin Suijkerbuijk
                                                                  Edwin Suijkerbuijk  6 months back

                                                                  how do people think Young Griff might effect the ending in the books to the ending in the show ?

                                                                  • danofthedead1979
                                                                    danofthedead1979  6 months back

                                                                    After a second watching, i dont hate the finale as much as i did after the first watching.

                                                                    • Jonnie Of House Harrison
                                                                      Jonnie Of House Harrison  6 months back

                                                                      You can now stop having to suffer watching what you love be butchered. Thank you so much for continuing with the reviews through the years even when it must have been emotionally hard for you.
                                                                      Lots of love to you and Elio.
                                                                      Back to George content for everyone.

                                                                      • rukan rukan
                                                                        rukan rukan  6 months back

                                                                        that part you said about when they zoom in on bran's eye that there would be a icy glint, i also thought that would happen :P i think i would have preferred that...

                                                                        • AlternativeExplosion
                                                                          AlternativeExplosion  6 months back

                                                                          We will miss your reviews, Linda. These videos were a fun journey, even if by the end we were swimming in a sewer...
                                                                          Hope you do more Asoiaf related videos. :D

                                                                          • Max Starling
                                                                            Max Starling  6 months back

                                                                            There was a wee bit of red in the black dress. It shows when she walks away at the end of the weird fascist rally scene.

                                                                            • OneOnOne1162
                                                                              OneOnOne1162  6 months back

                                                                              The show became pretty terrible by the end, but personally I will always be glad for the first few seasons and for those seasons getting me into the "A Song of Ice & Fire" universe. Before the show I'm sad to say I'd never heard of these books, but since then I've read all the books multiple times, read "The World of Ice & Fire" and the Dunk & Egg novellas and "Fire & Blood" and enjoyed them all so much. I even have a Longclaw replica. And I've enjoyed hashing out theories and speculating on characters and themes with all of my fellow fans.

                                                                              • voice2voiceless
                                                                                voice2voiceless  6 months back

                                                                                100% Agreed. Same with me, I read the books before I watched the show, but that's only after the show became popular (season 3). So, I do owe the show that at least. And I also fell in love with the actors and love that now we can see them in other things. That being said, I will erase Season 7 and 8 from my memory hahaha

                                                                            • horseofkhorne
                                                                              horseofkhorne  6 months back

                                                                              I am a bit confused over the dismissal of the logistics of elective monarchy. It has its faults, huge faults, but it has worked in history and there are many examples. Limited to just the high lords it is similar to the Holy Roman Empire, or with all nobles its more Polish Lithuanian commonwealth to name just two.
                                                                              If Cardinals can gather to elect the Pope, or the Electors of the Holy Roman Empire, or the members of the Thing in Saxon history, or the very early caliphate ext, then the lords of Westeros can.

                                                                              • OneOnOne1162
                                                                                OneOnOne1162  6 months back

                                                                                I pretty much agree with the speculations on the end. I think, somewhat like George said, they had the broad strokes there but lost a lot of the complexity. Dany will go crazy and be killed, Jon will do the killing and go beyond the wall, Arya will sail to the west of Westeros, Brienne will become lord commander, etc. But none of it will happen in the way it's presented here. There'll be more to it. Like it might be clear that Jon's exile is in part a self-exile, no longer wanting to take part in any politics or power plays or wars. Arya's path of vengeance will have permanent consequences for her, leaving her scarred. I do think it's possible an elective monarchy will happen, but I think if so it'll be in the form of a great council. They've used those to settle succession disputes before and I think it's possible that it will transition to the function of electing new monarchs on the death of the old. The biggest problem I have with the end is probably the idea of the North seceding. I find it very hard to buy that happening. Mostly because I think that would, from a realistic standpoint, inevitably cause a domino effect. Like I would imagine Dorne would immediately ask for the same thing. And George is a stickler for political realism in a way that D&D never were. So yeah... find it hard to believe that'll happen in the books. But you never know, maybe he'll find a way to do it realistically.

                                                                                • KMello
                                                                                  KMello  6 months back

                                                                                  This ending only made me feel “used.”
                                                                                  The story will not only continue with pre sequels but now they left it
                                                                                  *Wide open* to have a continued story. Some where in the future. Ten years from now? 🤦‍♀️
                                                                                  The GOT franchise *LIVES ON*

                                                                                  • UnDead Polo
                                                                                    UnDead Polo  6 months back

                                                                                    But we all died inside for it.

                                                                                • OneOnOne1162
                                                                                  OneOnOne1162  6 months back

                                                                                  I was alright with Drogon nudging Dany, I actually thought that was quite emotional, and maybe even him rearing up in anger but him destroying the throne and then taking Dany with him... that seems a bit much. Dragons have never been shown to be intelligent enough to understand the sort of deductions it would take for him to do that, imo.

                                                                                  • Sandra X
                                                                                    Sandra X  6 months back

                                                                                    I feel cheated by Dany’s turn into madness, I feel like I skipped a season of development. I really hate when people say “oh if you did not see that coming...” well, not like this, give me other facts than killing her enemies, because that’s what Westerosi leaders/characters have been doing, being brutal with their enemies has been the theme with all characters, like R Baratheon accepting the killing of the Targs even the children, Arya killing the Freys, Meryn Trant etc. Sansa enjoying watching Ramsey being eaten alive... Why expect something different from Daenerys? Now she kills civilians... but why? Oh yes she was mad all along because her father was mad... I just feel sad that all the intricacy of the story, was gone... Like with Bran I’m totally baffled, he did absolutely nothing, his “training” was only to be the back up disk for history? Why make a big deal of him being a powerful green seer that could warg people, visit the past, and that could even change something (Hodor) or be heard (Ned) during a vision? I’m not even mad anymore, just disappointed. Thank you Linda, for your insight as always. I’m done with the Starks really, not just Sansa, I was pro-Starks before, but now I’m just drained by them. I must disagree 😅 about the winged-Daenerys scene, I personally loved it, I will treasure that visual! and also maybe the scenes were Drogon is nudging Dany’s body and Jon is with Ghost. I’m soft like that 😬😂

                                                                                    • Hellenyi
                                                                                      Hellenyi  6 months back

                                                                                      Can I vote for Linda on the iron (melted) throne? :-D
                                                                                      Thank you for you analysis of the episodes, I really enjoyed them all, since the begining of the series!

                                                                                      • Linda Antonsson
                                                                                        Linda Antonsson  6 months back

                                                                                        I'll wait until it has cooled off, at least. ;)

                                                                                    • SimplyWanda
                                                                                      SimplyWanda  6 months back

                                                                                      Hated Sansa from first season and that never changed. I think Eddard would have been very unhappy with his daughter. She is no better than Cersei, Dany or Littlefinger. She learned all she knew from those three.

                                                                                      • SimplyWanda
                                                                                        SimplyWanda  6 months back

                                                                                        @S R Thank you. For being 11 (actually more like 13) during that time and place was marriage age and considered basically a young adult. Her character never changed. If you have a different opinion then good for you.

                                                                                      • kmsharley75
                                                                                        kmsharley75  6 months back

                                                                                        S R you can't really bring in her age,Arya was younger and still made better decisions.

                                                                                      • kmsharley75
                                                                                        kmsharley75  6 months back

                                                                                        Dany is better than her.

                                                                                      • S R
                                                                                        S R  6 months back

                                                                                        SimplyWanda so you basically hated an 11 year old girl for being naive so much that it skewed her whole story for you. Congrats.

                                                                                    • Krisztina Szőke
                                                                                      Krisztina Szőke  6 months back

                                                                                      The northeners meant that they won't bend the knee to any foreigner again. they never said they won't be a monarchy anymore and that they won't kneel to their own sovereign.

                                                                                      • The Letter Bleeds
                                                                                        The Letter Bleeds  6 months back

                                                                                        They should remake it but as an animated show. That would be more affordable.