Everything Wrong With Return of the Jedi


Comments • 2 077

  • CinemaSins
    CinemaSins   8 months back

    Hey guys! This video is a re-upload because the original version of this episode was no longer viewable. We’ll be posting these re-uploads every Saturday for the next few months. There are still NEW sins videos every Tuesday and Thursday!

    • zerooskul
      zerooskul  2 weeks back

      So light being shone through melting black ice layered over Harrison Ford and digitally enhanced in 1997 by ILM looks like an Atari?
      I play Atari 2600, BITCH! And I know the difference between a visual effect and a special effect.
      Toilet's in the bathroom. Lift the seat first. You'll get it, eventually.
      AND, YEAH, THIS MOVIE SUCKS!!! But you have no clue why, because you suck at watching and understanding movies, narrative, basic human movements, literary juxtaposition, timing, lighting, or the difference between chroma keying and rear projection.
      Don't fuck with Atari... unless you are critiquing a movie about Atari... like "Ready Player Dumb"!

    • X1AnonymousX2
      X1AnonymousX2  2 weeks back

      Everything wrong with my life

    • Darth_ Link
      Darth_ Link  3 months back

      You say that George Lucas was thinking hmmm how can I make a bad movie i know the to make a bad movie is to have Rian Johnson make it and add jar jar Binks boom a Terible movie

    • Mr.Wander-man
      Mr.Wander-man  3 months back

      Olivia Moore ;; ;nb

    • Lumbago Productions
      Lumbago Productions  4 months back

      CinemaSins 7:59 Those guys dressed in purple are actually the emperors advisors :)

  • Kolscor
    Kolscor  11 hours back

    Anyone else think that the thumbnail looks alike THE RETUM OF THE JEDI.


    Just me....


      XTRAORDINARY 01  13 hours back

      The only reason Anakin was his young self when he died was because that’s what he looked like before he turned to the dark side

      • Herr Darkurve
        Herr Darkurve  14 hours back

        Bar-2-D2 is the best thing ever.

        • Scott Ivy
          Scott Ivy  15 hours back

          15:19 Han gets some boob 😂😂

          • Dániel Benkó
            Dániel Benkó  16 hours back

            I guess all the other Jedi had to confront some terrible, extremely-difficult evil to become Jedi, too, huh?

            yea almost sounds as if there was a thing called Trials for padawans before they could become Jedies -thinking face-

            • Daddy Nose scope6664
              Daddy Nose scope6664  17 hours back

              17:56 just making up excuses to add more sins, its not even jar jar binks they are just random gungans

              • Tyson Geraci
                Tyson Geraci  1 days back

                He didn’t have his saber because R2 had it

                • Try HarderScrubs
                  Try HarderScrubs  1 days back

                  no sin off when he say obi wan taught you well luke has the high ground

                  • THE WOAT
                    THE WOAT  1 days back

                    Luke not having his lightsaber in the palace is the opposite of a sin in fact its the jedi way to use your saber as a last resort

                    • Bobby Turner
                      Bobby Turner  2 days back

                      Nothing is wrong with this movie

                      • Spencer Cox
                        Spencer Cox  2 days back

                        Good grief. when yoda dies, he dies SUPER FAST. like, there was no indication he would die except for him saying "you know, I won't be around forever", and them BAM!, he was literally on his death bed.

                        • the fastest meme in the west

                          0:50 has the gonk droid, how dare you call it a sin

                          • Shadow StrikeS
                            Shadow StrikeS  3 days back

                            Lol I just got an ad saying
                            “Can you make heads or tails on this”
                            “What is it now? Cinema sins? That makes no sense!”
                            “I know right”

                            • Kevo
                              Kevo  3 days back

                              Should have used the original version of the movie. It would have lowered the sin count. 🤣 The song changes, cgi aliens, force ghost change, and my most hated, Vader saying "Noooo" as he picks Palpatine up. Ughh it was unnecessary. Beautiful moment on its own.

                              • A Human
                                A Human  3 days back

                                15:20, I love how the emperor says “Use your aggressive feelings.”

                                • Rizzle K
                                  Rizzle K  4 days back

                                  Follow me on Instagram (actor)

                                  • Mde Creole Shelia
                                    Mde Creole Shelia  4 days back

                                    Unfortunately Palpatine is was still alive and Rey had to kill him

                                    • Ian K
                                      Ian K  4 days back

                                      You can't sin "A long time ago in a galaxy far far away..." and R2-D2. They're too iconic.

                                      • Tommy Irwin
                                        Tommy Irwin  4 days back

                                        He didn't have his lightsaber with him cuz he gave it to R2

                                        • UncleSam
                                          UncleSam  4 days back


                                          • Julian.Aguiniga Aguiniga

                                            Nothing is wrong with this movie it’s perfect the best Star Wars movie and personally my favorite movie of all time

                                            • ST_Category7
                                              ST_Category7  5 days back

                                              he missed one sin:

                                              When luke was carrying Darth Vader to the ship with all the stormtroopers around, why didn't they just shoot him? He doesn't have a lightsaber

                                              • ST_Category7
                                                ST_Category7  4 days back

                                                @Chopper I know, but it doesn't take that long to shoot a gun and run

                                              • Chopper
                                                Chopper  4 days back

                                                ST_Category7 All of them were focused on saving themselves

                                            • Mr Bear
                                              Mr Bear  5 days back

                                              Channel Sins : Too many swearing.

                                            • Turtle Master 24
                                              Turtle Master 24  5 days back

                                              The Sarlacc keeps you alive for all 1000 years.

                                              • Golden State Warriors
                                                Golden State Warriors  6 days back

                                                Not taking off sins for "I am a Jedi, like my father before me."

                                                • ventuist
                                                  ventuist  4 days back

                                                  Golden State Warriors oops sorry i misread it

                                                • Golden State Warriors
                                                  Golden State Warriors  4 days back

                                                  @ventuist I know sins shouldve been taken off for that cause its pretty epic.

                                                • ventuist
                                                  ventuist  5 days back

                                                  Golden State Warriors he is referring to his father as anakin skywalker not darth vader

                                              • SanDeezy_ Breezy
                                                SanDeezy_ Breezy  6 days back

                                                Speaking of Raiders of the Lost Ark, when the hell are you going to do the Indiana Jones trilogy?!

                                                • Jacob Naugle
                                                  Jacob Naugle  6 days back

                                                  There are three incorrect sins. We now have comics that detail what Luke did between TESB, & ROTJ. There has also been great mention of how Anakin died before Darth Vader was born, so that is why his forceghost is much younger.

                                                  • Random Noob
                                                    Random Noob  6 days back

                                                    Counting sins for stuff that is in the books

                                                    • Ryan Thorstensen
                                                      Ryan Thorstensen  6 days back

                                                      this hurts my feelings

                                                      • OMEGA-P _74
                                                        OMEGA-P _74  6 days back

                                                        Coolest thing about "Star Wars" is Darth Vader and James Earles Jones voice as Darth Vader.

                                                        • Kloopie
                                                          Kloopie  7 days back

                                                          The first 54 seconds and my gonk droid is being tortured
                                                          One like = one f to pay respects

                                                          • droid attack on the wookies Daily

                                                            16:50: palpatene survives this * ding *

                                                            • droid attack on the wookies Daily
                                                              droid attack on the wookies Daily  6 days back

                                                              @blue_pearl_22 it was Anakins redemption how is that cheap?

                                                            • blue_pearl_22
                                                              blue_pearl_22  6 days back

                                                              I always thought it was a cheap ass "death" anyway so I'm glad he survived. If Luke could survive his fall in Empire than it shouldn't be that hard for the strongest Sith in the galaxy either.

                                                          • Eric Enerlich
                                                            Eric Enerlich  1 weeks back

                                                            I love that Jedi song in Jabbas palace

                                                            • Matthew Wang
                                                              Matthew Wang  1 weeks back

                                                              Wtf was that ad of budget direct with cinema sins

                                                              • Fezezen
                                                                Fezezen  1 weeks back

                                                                You missed the air wiff kick

                                                                • Transfromers guy Gaming

                                                                  james earl Jones is the voice actor of darth vader.

                                                                  • Ticcy
                                                                    Ticcy  1 weeks back

                                                                    Luke: gets the high ground

                                                                    Vader: obi wan has taught you well

                                                                    • Supreme Leader Ren
                                                                      Supreme Leader Ren  1 weeks back

                                                                      Sin #57’s not valid because the original trilogy was before the prequels and they changed it so you should sin episode 1 not this one
                                                                      #97 yeah no he felt he was NEAR. The Death Star is next to the planet they never said he was on it

                                                                      • Judoboy
                                                                        Judoboy  1 weeks back

                                                                        15:37 no he’s saying that because he has the high ground🤦‍♂️

                                                                        • Judoboy
                                                                          Judoboy  5 days back

                                                                          blue_pearl_22 joke bro😐

                                                                        • blue_pearl_22
                                                                          blue_pearl_22  6 days back

                                                                          That explanation didn't work back when this movie first came out cause it depends on knowledge form the prequels.

                                                                      • Blippy Raccoon
                                                                        Blippy Raccoon  1 weeks back

                                                                        "suck my furry ass*

                                                                        • TheShadowPlayz
                                                                          TheShadowPlayz  1 weeks back

                                                                          The Empire isn't using R2 compatible hardware, all droids are built with the same activator system. They're using R2-W5 compatible hardware.

                                                                          • Darryl Bradley
                                                                            Darryl Bradley  2 days back

                                                                            @TheShadowPlayz the birdman is irrelevant, both to the conversation and in general. Dude made a joke and you accused him of not liking star wars. You took it waaaay to serious. Hence the woosh.

                                                                          • TheShadowPlayz
                                                                            TheShadowPlayz  2 days back

                                                                            @Darryl Bradley The Neeeerd thing wasn't a movie reference. I wasn't being technical, it's that CinemaSins asked why they used R2-D2 compatible hardware, and I answered that they use astromechs too. Have you ever watched Th3BirdMan?

                                                                          • Darryl Bradley
                                                                            Darryl Bradley  3 days back

                                                                            @TheShadowPlayz no. It's a wooosh. You got super technical about something, and he said neeeerd. It's a movie reference. Ya got wooshed. You missed the joke.

                                                                          • TheShadowPlayz
                                                                            TheShadowPlayz  4 days back

                                                                            @Darryl Bradley It's not a wooosh for me if he's the one that doesn't understand.

                                                                          • Darryl Bradley
                                                                            Darryl Bradley  4 days back

                                                                            @TheShadowPlayz r/wooosh

                                                                        • David Gockel
                                                                          David Gockel  1 weeks back

                                                                          My favorite scene is where Luke cuts off Vaders Hand and the Emperor stands up, applauses and tells him to take his fathers place by his side. Luke then proceeds to throw his lightsaber away and say "No, I'm a Jedi like my father was before me" like what the heck did he expect to happen from there?

                                                                          • Thomas Parsons
                                                                            Thomas Parsons  1 weeks back

                                                                            How much do you say deus ex machina?

                                                                            • Musky Boi
                                                                              Musky Boi  1 weeks back

                                                                              Those purple guys could be the Aliens in the phantom menace with the racist japanese accents

                                                                              • Joey Black
                                                                                Joey Black  1 weeks back

                                                                                15:40 he gives the credit to obi-wan because he has taken the high ground

                                                                                • blue_pearl_22
                                                                                  blue_pearl_22  6 days back

                                                                                  considering the audience couldn't have known that back when this movie first came out since that knowledge is based on the prequels, it's still a valid sin imo.

                                                                              • Angry Visions Gaming
                                                                                Angry Visions Gaming  1 weeks back

                                                                                I got a budget direct ad that said cinema sins

                                                                                • Agent1W
                                                                                  Agent1W  1 weeks back

                                                                                  14:21 In the ewoks' defense, they are a primitive race of the galaxy and nowhere near as advanced as many of the others. What can we expect from a people who are stuck in the human equivalent of the Tool Age? Not a whole lot, but their paltry contributions did serve as fanciful distractions and meat shields for the actual Rebel commandos.

                                                                                  • Agent1W
                                                                                    Agent1W  6 days back

                                                                                    @blue_pearl_22 With Rebel Alliance "Green Beret" collaboration, it's just like how the mujahideen stopped the Soviets: the big difference was weapons and their use. Naturally, the Rebels had little time and insufficient materiel to teach ewoks how to use blasters.

                                                                                    To put more critical thinking into play, that's probably how the Imperials were able to install shield generators without any serious fuss. They knew the ewoks, a druidic and superstitious ancient world people, would not be a threat they'd have to subjugate. It's passable in this movie, but not by themselves and definitely not by a serious fleet of Imperials.

                                                                                  • blue_pearl_22
                                                                                    blue_pearl_22  6 days back

                                                                                    Yet they are capable of taking down the majority of the strike force of the highly advanced Empire with slingshots and booby traps LOL