The Disaster that was Telltale's Game of Thrones #GoT #gameofthrones #asoiaf


Comments • 1 147

  • Konráð Ingi
    Konráð Ingi  6 months back

    *Cat will remember that*

    • Sölvi Sveinbjörnsson
      Sölvi Sveinbjörnsson  6 months back

      Þessi var góður Konráð

    • TheRaudmagi
      TheRaudmagi  6 months back

      Takk fyrir Konráð minn

    • vice vice
      vice vice  6 months back

      i wanted to say that, but at least i gave the upvote that made the like ratio 169

  • fashnek
    fashnek  1 months back

    I was going along for the first 25% but your commentary on the visuals of the game is so ridiculous. I couldn't keep watching after seeing the video go that way. Off at 8:00

    • Rock Universe Gaming
      Rock Universe Gaming  1 months back

      Great game, makes season 8 look worse.

      • Salokin92
        Salokin92  2 months back

        This review was so terrible...
        You have a few valid points, but other gripes are far too subjective.

        • Jesse Cook
          Jesse Cook  3 months back

          "Ramsey Snow has better things to do than be a cartoon villain"

          Excuse you, but that is exactly what he normally does. He's just going a bit farther than usual to do so.

          • Faith Murri
            Faith Murri  3 months back

            I forgot that I tried playing this until I saw a clip that looked familiar

            • jordy0702
              jordy0702  3 months back

              get fucked, this game was good lol, sucks they can't make a season 2.

              • Mega4Fun
                Mega4Fun  3 months back

                I played it back to back and enjoyed it tbh

                • SuomiPerkele
                  SuomiPerkele  3 months back

                  17:55 like every telltale games, they are all like that.

                  • Drake
                    Drake  4 months back

                    "They've got two different colored endings, that's one less than mass effect!" Instant rage! Mass Effect easily the worst insult a game developer has done for the end of a game series.

                    • Robin Banks
                      Robin Banks  4 months back

                      This is the case with every Telltale game, dude. I’m not saying that excuses it but I’m not going to pretend that my choices ever actually mattered in the long run when it comes to TellTale as the’ve always have us the illusion of choice and nothing more. Telltale spitting on just about every choice you’ve made makes me kind of glad they shut down. Season 2 of their Walking Dead games has multiple endings but none of them mattered as 2 years later they would all be disregarded anyway. It was a big middle finger to their audience. They gotten way to greedy by making too many games off of licensed franchises in way too short of a time and the games could’ve been better if they actually took their time instead of trying to profit off of popular source material as much and as quickly as possible. I would say that their shutdown was karma coming back on them, or at least partly.

                      • WWE Rules252
                        WWE Rules252  4 months back

                        One if my fav telltale still play it to this day

                        • Michael Nally
                          Michael Nally  4 months back

                          I didn’t think this game was that bad honestly. I just found a good chunk of the choice “options” to be meaningless like I remember in the first episode when I got into the scuffle at the pig farm. I killed one guy and had another at sword point and I found the option to spare him or kill him pointless as I got sent to the wall regardless so might as well kill him.

                          • mow mow
                            mow mow  4 months back

                            The game was now vanished from play store .

                            • lexa 2t
                              lexa 2t  5 months back

                              Totally agree at first I liked the game and the storyline but upon finishing it I wanted to try a different ending because having all the forester house murdered wasn't the greatest ending. I litteraly spent hours replaying the entire game and nothing changed. Same stupid ending. None of the choices do anything. So disappointing.

                              • Ferrohazard
                                Ferrohazard  5 months back

                                But how would you rate this against "Game of Thrones: Winter Is Coming (tm) The officially licensed browser game"?

                                • Jetto Scranda
                                  Jetto Scranda  5 months back

                                  Seriously guys, screw the series, they should make a game loyal to the books! Did you know that in the books the army of the dead had pale spiders of the size of hounds? This is just an example. This game could be better than Dark Souls, just saying.

                                  • Jetto Scranda
                                    Jetto Scranda  5 months back

                                    This game will adapt according to the choices you make. The story is tailored by how you play - So far every TellTale game I played had this disclaimer, and no choice impacted the actual gameplay much, if at all.

                                    • Hayden Molles
                                      Hayden Molles  5 months back

                                      Elden Ring would the best GoT not GoT game to be relesesd

                                      • ChelseaFcTheChamps
                                        ChelseaFcTheChamps  5 months back

                                        Music at minute 6?

                                        • Bilal Keskin
                                          Bilal Keskin  5 months back

                                          Yes this game sucked so haarddd it was really bad.

                                          • adolf hitler
                                            adolf hitler  5 months back

                                            I honored enjoyed the game. I never watched game of thrones but decided to play this game and I enjoyed it. I finished the game and was thinking about starting over and see if my choices can change anything. But after I found out that I couldn't choose anything I was disappointed. But I still want to give it a go again

                                            • powercore2000
                                              powercore2000  5 months back

                                              You seems to go overly harsh on the graphics, they were serviceable to me, and nice looking in places. You did have a point with the edge fraying, but the complaint for a lack of particle effects is pretty nit picky.

                                              • HE1NZ
                                                HE1NZ  6 months back

                                                Personally I don't mind the gameplay or Telltale formula. My problem with this is that the story is just brutal, even more so than the show, and makes it seem like you choose wrong every time. Unlike TWD though there's no Clementine moments to make keep going.

                                                • Princesoulger
                                                  Princesoulger  6 months back

                                                  So this game never had an ending ?
                                                  This is an accurate A Song of Ice & Fire game

                                                  • LeviathanSpeaks1469
                                                    LeviathanSpeaks1469  6 months back

                                                    Telltale should have done a 40K game instead...

                                                    • HolyknightVader999
                                                      HolyknightVader999  6 months back

                                                      Ramsay killing noble children makes no sense. If anything, he'd probably kill the elder members of the family BEFORE the children, flay them living, then let the kids take over the house, so he has some scared little rats managing castles for him, who know the price of defiance. That's what he did in the show.

                                                      • HolyknightVader999
                                                        HolyknightVader999  6 months back

                                                        I would argue that anti-plot armor is worse than plot armor. At least with characters that have plot armor, you can be certain that they're going to be around for quite some time, so you can invest in their character, or at least predict how the plot will go when they show up. With anti-plot armor, people just STOP investing in the characters, because why the fuck would they bet on a horse with crippled legs? It's as if they made you play as Team Rocket from Pokemon and all you do is get your ass blasted off from one end of the country to another. The Forresters' story is basically just fucking torture porn at this point.

                                                        They might as well read bondage fanfiction in random websites instead, because at least the characters tied up in those stories can give the reader something interesting to read as the main characters squirm in their bonds while the bad guys do whatever the hell they want. If people have to choose between experiencing the story of A) a house of nobles who get so much bad luck that even the black cats avoid them out of fear, or B) some young, hot gal tied up by some horny twat who does things to make her even more excited, nine times out of ten, they'll choose B, because at least, it's enjoyable. If they want a story of a hero who remains true despite facing death itself, there's no shortage of stories of heroic last stands from both history and fiction for them to read.

                                                        • Darth Sei'vanhys
                                                          Darth Sei'vanhys  6 months back

                                                          Actually I liked it.

                                                          • Mr. Divery
                                                            Mr. Divery  6 months back

                                                            Everyone I know who played it liked this game, myself included. It is very much the illusion of choice but it is entertaining. Iron from Ice.

                                                            • slimpyman
                                                              slimpyman  6 months back

                                                              This game looked good. My gf and I loved the art style. This dude sounds like an idiot

                                                              • Luke Butler
                                                                Luke Butler  6 months back

                                                                What pisses me off more than the quality of this game. Is that it'll never even be finished.

                                                                • Gary
                                                                  Gary  6 months back

                                                                  It's not that bad to be honest, it's just you circlejerking and bandwagoning along with the GoT hate D&D received for S8.

                                                                  • Uncle #1
                                                                    Uncle #1  6 months back

                                                                    I actually enjoyed the Game of thrones telltale game.

                                                                    • Kadleth Belmont
                                                                      Kadleth Belmont  6 months back

                                                                      I disagree. One plays this game for the story, not the platformer controls or the RPG elements which it wasn't supposed to have. The game looked well enough in 2014 when released. The specs were low to increase hardware support. Didn't have problems playing it on the XB One.
                                                                      The illusion of choice is real & the greatest disappointment. I still enjoyed being able to experience the POV of a lower house dragged into the events in Westeros. It is not entirely canon either. The Whitehills are not really as close to the Boltons & the Forresters are not as grand a house.

                                                                      • Steven Pham Nguyen
                                                                        Steven Pham Nguyen  6 months back

                                                                        Shit video LOL look at that dislike ratio

                                                                        • t3hKazy
                                                                          t3hKazy  6 months back

                                                                          Are you actively, purposefully idiotic? TTG games are visual novels with 3D models, and all you're bitching about is how a visual novel lacks action or game mechanics.

                                                                          • iBeFloe
                                                                            iBeFloe  6 months back

                                                                            I feel like there’s just too much dialogue in GOT for it to be a game lol You’re basically having to read a novel

                                                                            • RAB2784
                                                                              RAB2784  6 months back

                                                                              I enjoyed this game I have to say & could easily play it again

                                                                              • Mofo CREEED
                                                                                Mofo CREEED  6 months back

                                                                                That like bar if only 1000 people actually bought tell-tale games :p

                                                                                • R
                                                                                  R  6 months back

                                                                                  The disaster that is game of thrones as a franchise tbh. There's no good games or comic books, the spin-off books are just acceptable, the first half of the TV show is great, the second half is an abomination. First half of the books are great as well, last 2 books were a boring festival, etc.. ASOIF/GoT is just another example of a niche genre, this time dark fantasy, becoming extremely popular out of nowhere and when things started to grown to a franchise state, the quality dropped significantly. The TV show already spoiled the ending, Martin is a lazy fuck, his last 2 books were not good at all and now he will delay a story that we already know the major plot points for another 10 years or so? C'mon, lol I will not stay attached to this franchise anymore if George ressurects Jon Snow, that will be the last straw.

                                                                                  • HoBrosGaming
                                                                                    HoBrosGaming  6 months back

                                                                                    I remember playing this game back in the day. It felt like them copying the plotlines and character arcs of the show but with random no name characters you don't know or care about.

                                                                                    • DrunkNLucky
                                                                                      DrunkNLucky  6 months back

                                                                                      In the least, it definitely wasn’t made for pc

                                                                                      • sure xavage
                                                                                        sure xavage  6 months back

                                                                                        I personally loved ot

                                                                                        • Toaster Boy
                                                                                          Toaster Boy  6 months back

                                                                                          Also there animators where not paid and had to work long hours no wonder it was so bad also what writers did they hire, forgot to mention they had a lack of funding.

                                                                                          • Mama Platts
                                                                                            Mama Platts  6 months back

                                                                                            13:05 wait wich movies?

                                                                                            • Crackwhore Squarepants
                                                                                              Crackwhore Squarepants  6 months back

                                                                                              Sounds like you’re just tryna shit on the game for the sake of shitting on game of thrones because of the end of the show. This game was enjoyable and most people enjoyed it, just look at your comment section. Everyone loved tell tale games.

                                                                                              • Boog S Reviews
                                                                                                Boog S Reviews  6 months back

                                                                                                I for one liked every episode. I played them in a week last year and loved it. I just hate it ended it on a cliffhanger. But I can’t fault them for that since a sequel was going to be out this year if they hadn’t went under. I loved the big fight at the end of episode 5. I played on PS4 and didn’t have any glitches or problems with the controls.